Johann Sebastian Bach and George Friderick Handel were two of the most
important composers of the Baroque Period. Compare and contrast their lives and
sacred musical works studied in class.
Johann Sebastian Bach and George Friderick Handel are two of the most
important composers of the Baroque period. Born only one month apart both in
Germany. Handel lived nine more years than Bach. Coming from the same period
the two composers have many qualities that are alike and some unlike. These
qualities include the time frames of their childhood, adult hood and later years as well
as a comparison between two sacred musical pieces.
Bach and Handel, though both born in Germany only one month apart, they
came from different family lifestyles. George Handel did not come from a musical
family, his father wanted him to study law. By age 9, his talent was too obvious and
began to study with a local organist and composer. Whereas Johann Bach came
from a long line of musicians. Four of his own sons became composers. Bach also
started as an organist and composer, but as a church organist.
At the age of 18 Handel went to Hamburg and became a violinist and a
harpsichordist in the orchestra. In the meantime Bach was a court conductor for the
Prince of Cothen, it was his first position that was not involved in the church or organ
music. Bach later became a director of must at St. Thomas church where he stayed
for the next 27 years. At the age of 21 Handel was successfully producing operas.
He later went to Italy where he associated with famous musicians and princes.
Handel became knows as Englands most important composer. Bach was not
considered the greatest composer of his day, but he was recognized as the greatest
organist and harpsichordist. Handel wrote suites, organ concertos, concerti grossi but
mostly oratorios and Italian operas. Bach wrote all forms of Baroque music, all except
Operas. Bach was a deeply religious man; Handel wrote oratorios based from stories
of the Old Testament, but it was not church music. Backs music, for example
Brandenburg Concerto No. 5 is a display of virtuosity, cadenza. Highlight of the solo
includes: improvising, scales, appregio, ornamentation and trills. Handels music has
Bachs Cantata No. 140, is one of his best known cantatas. Unlike Handels
Messiah, Cantata No. 140 is a 130 year old chorale tune. Messiah was composed in
twenty four days.
Awake, A Voice is Calling Us, was already well known. Messiah was
not popular for over ten years. The use of Christian text performed in theater was
not well received by some. Messiah, is in three parts; while Awake, A Voice is Calling
Us, has seven movements. Messiah was Handels only English oratorio that was the
New Testament as also the Old Testament.
Bach and Handel come from different types of family, but born in the same
country and very close in age. Bach was more involved in the church than Handel,
even though Handel used religious material for his music. Both of the composers
were great organist and in their old age, their eyesight worsened. Bach and Handel
both continued to compose music with no or little eyesight. The most similar
characteristic both Bach and Handel share is the fact that they brought amazing
music to this world to share with all.
Beethoven presents the best of both Classical and Romantic ideals in music.
Discuss why this is so. Be sure to include in your discussion, examples of his music
Beethoven presents the best of both Classical and Romantic ideals in music.
Beethoven was known to have bridged the gap between Classical music and
Romanticism. An example that can show qualities of both periods, can be done by
defining each time and then comparing with a piece such as Beethovens Symphony
The Classical Period can be defined as the age of reason or enlightenment.
Faith was a power of reason. Wealth and power are represented musically and with
simplicity. It shows refinement, ease balance and symmetry. For the music, texture
was homophonic, rhythm had greater variety in meter, melodies were more simple,
dynamics changed: crescendo and decrescendo, and the orchestras increased in size
and added woodwinds and brass. Harpsichords were replaced by a piano. Sonata
form was introduced for both orchestral and chamber work.
The Romantic period can be described as a wealth of emotion such as
jealousy, intimacy, anger and betrayal. Music is a reflection of the composers
personality. Subject matters became fantasy or dreams. Nationalism became
present due to show love of ones country and to show pride.
Beethoven mostly used classical forms, but the power of emotion displayed
represented Romantic qualities. Much of his style and technique was used later by
other composers in the Romantic era.
Beethovens Symphony No. 5 is written in sonata form of the classical period,
and performed by large orchestras, yet eludes emotion as in the Romantic period.
The opening theme is in minor and creates tension. As the piece progresses
emotionally, it ends triumphantly is a major key. The four opening notes,
short-short-short-long, sounds like a march like them from the third movement. The
march-like can be related to nationalism which is a prominent quality in Romantic
music. It also shows power and wealth with whom Beethoven associated with.
The most obvious characteristic in Romantic music is the fact that a composer
shows so much passion and emotion or nationalism in their music. Beethovens
Symphony No. 5 is a good example that possesses all of those qualities, yet is written
in sonata form from the Classical period.